Greenpeace is anti-farmer; Govt ignored SM contract

Greenpeace International, the Amsterdam-based environmental advocate, is robbing Filipino farmers of their chance to increase agricultural productivity and mocking the world food security program.

Ranged against Filipino scientists, Greenpeace is doing all it can to stop the Philippines from expanding the adoption of pesticide-free crop varieties. It wants to ban the field testing of Bt Talong, an eggplant variety developed by scientists that does not require pesticide because of a built-in resistance against pests.

For Greenpeace, the improved crop is unfit for human consumption. It initially obtained a Writ of Kalikasan from the Court of Appeals to stop the field testing. But Filipino scientists, along with farmers, asked the Supreme Court to lift the ban and allow them to complete field tests for Bt Talong. The tests are a required step before the plant variety goes into commercialization.

The ban on field tests has deprived Filipino farmers of their basic freedom of choice. The completion of field trials on Bt Talong and the eventual approval for commercialization would give local farmers the right to select the crop fit for their livelihood earnings. They can either opt to plant the biotech variety, which does not need the traditional use of chemical pesticides, or stick with the conventional eggplant that has to be sprayed with the substance.

The issue of food safety is a scientific one which local scientists and Greenpeace’s activists are currently debating. In the ensuing arguments, Greenpeace claimed the plants developed using biotechnology were not good for the Filipinos. The local science community, meanwhile, said the modern agriculture biotechnology was vital to food security and that crops developed through that process were as safe, “if not safer,” than traditional types.

Leading the effort to adopt Bt Talong is Dr. Emil Javier, the 17th president of the University of the Philippines and an American-educated expert on plant genetics. Dr. Javier is also a former chancellor of UP Los Baños, the country’s premiere hub for agriculture research, and has made it a personal cause to promote the role of plant science in improving the lives of farmers and consumers alike.

Aiding Javier in the defense of the safety of biotechnology is Dr. Kenneth Y. Hartigan-Go, a former Asian Institute of Management and UP College of Medicine professor, who was named head of the Food and Drugs Administration in 2012.

The stakes in the Bt Talong case are larger. The future of scientific research in the development of crop varieties that can withstand one of the food production sector’s biggest challenges—massive infestation, such as what the coconut industry is facing today—now hangs in the balance.

DoTC’s silence

The Department of Transportation and Communications may have seen greener pastures nearby to evade officials of SM Prime Holdings Inc., after signing a contract on a central light rail transit station in 2009.

But SM Prime officials do not see it that way. They view DoTC’s maneuvering as a clear violation of the sanctity of contract approved by the National Economic and Development Authority in 2009.

“It is really the fault of DoTC and the Light Rail Transit Authority, which refused to reply to five letters we sent to clarify their press announcements that the central station will be beside Trinoma. Even in various SMPHI meetings with them, they refuse to say if they have changed the site. They just said at North Edsa, which they know is as vague as you can get,” an SM Prime source said.

The DoTC and LRTA virtually ripped the documents on the common rail station when the two agencies included it in the auction for the LRT Line I Cavite Extension project.

SM Prime, as a result, has asked a Pasay regional trial court to stop the DoTC from relocating the site of the common station to Trinoma shopping mall, owned by Ayala Land Inc.

SM Prime said the Neda-Investment Coordination Committee approved the location during the previous administration on July 7, 2009. In exchange, SM Prime paid LRTA P200 million as “naming rights.”

SM Prime also said it was not informed of any expiration date of the contract, which involved building a common station connecting Light Rail Transit Line 1, Metro Rail Transit Line 3 and the future MRT-7, which will run from the common station to Bulacan via Commonwealth Avenue.

SM Prime blamed the department and the LRTA for actually delaying the construction of the common station. “They cannot use their failure to timely implement the project to justify a sudden change in the location of the station. They cannot use what was caused by their own fault to throw our contract away,” the property developer said.


COMMENT DISCLAIMER: Reader comments posted on this Web site are not in any way endorsed by Manila Standard. Comments are views by readers who exercise their right to free expression and they do not necessarily represent or reflect the position or viewpoint of While reserving this publication’s right to delete comments that are deemed offensive, indecent or inconsistent with Manila Standard editorial standards, Manila Standard may not be held liable for any false information posted by readers in this comments section.