News Flash

August 04, 2015, Tuesday
  • Comelec says the planned extension of campaign period will prevent candidates from abusing the election rules. 15 hours ago |
  • Comelec considers the extension of campaign period for local candidates from current 45 days to 120 days. 15 hours ago |
  • Comelec mulls the extension of campaign period from current 90 days to 120 days for national candidates. 15 hours ago |
  • Abad says Sec. Mar Roxas will step down once Pres. Aquino has found his replacement at the DILG. 15 hours ago |
  • Binay says more Filipinos have become poor & are experiencing hunger after 5 years under the Aquino administration. 15 hours ago |
  • Binay enumerated the alleged dismal gov’t response during the tragedies in Luneta, Zamboanga, Mamasapano & Tacloban during ‘Yolanda.’ 15 hours ago |
  • Abad says Binay had clapped his hands for the Aquino administration when he was part of it for the last 4 years. 15 hours ago |
  • Binay says MRT, BBL and DAP symbolize the huge failures of the Aquino administration. 15 hours ago |
  • Binay delivers his 40-minute counter-SONA in front of a jam-packed crowd in Cavite State University in Indang, Cavite. 15 hours ago |
  • Sen. Marcos hopes the bullet hole found in his satellite office has no link to the Senate BBL deliberations which he is leading. 15 hours ago |
  • Sen. Bongbong Marcos hopes that what hit his satellite office was just a stray bullet. 15 hours ago |
  • Police investigate a bullet hole found on Sunday at the satellite office of Sen. Bongbong Marcos along Roxas Boulevard. 15 hours ago |
  • House to resume plenary session on BBL on Tuesday. 20 hours ago |
  • Tesda to provide training and livelihood programs for PWDs. 20 hours ago |
  • Shell to implement oil price rollback on Tuesday. 20 hours ago |
  • Pres. Aquino hopes Binay will honor his pledge to serve the people by giving them the right information. 20 hours ago |
  • Pres. Aquino urges Binay to stick to the facts when he delivers his counter-SONA on Monday afternoon. 20 hours ago |
  • Pres. Aquino says Roxas has agreed to stay longer in cabinet so long as proper turnover is guaranteed. 20 hours ago |
  • Pres. Aquino plans to ask Roxas to stay a little longer at the DILG to finish some things. 20 hours ago |
  • Pres. Aquino off to attend BIR's 111th Anniversary in Quezon City on Monday. 22 hours ago |
  • DND hopes China will be sincere in using the 'hotline' that will be opened to ASEAN members as they tackle sea disputes. 22 hours ago |
  • DILG Sec. Mar Roxas may submit his resignation letter to Malacanang on Monday afternoon. 22 hours ago |
  • DILG Sec. Mar Roxas says goodbye to policemen at the flag-raising ceremony in Camp Crame on Monday morning. 22 hours ago |
  • Sec. Mar Roxas reportedly prefers DILG Usec. Austere Panadero to replace him at the DILG. 22 hours ago |
  • Western Samar Rep. Mel Senen Sarmiento & Iloilo Rep. Niel Tupas Jr. reportedly being considered for DILG post. 22 hours ago |
  • Coloma says BBL must be approved by the present congress because peace in Mindanao cannot wait. 22 hours ago |
  • Coloma says Pres. Aquino will not wait for the next congress to pass the proposed BBL. 22 hours ago |

After the Zamboanga hostage-taking

Sep. 17, 2013 at 12:01am
At the outset, let me be clear where I stand on what is happening in Zamboanga City which, as I write this column, is on its eighth day. For me, this is clearly a criminal incident, a case principally of hostage-taking by a faction of the Moro National Liberation Front that has resulted in many deaths, disrupted the lives of more than 60,000 people, and destabilized Zamboanga Hermosa -- one of the most beautiful cities of this country.

There is no justification for this. More particularly, using civilians, especially children, as human shields is completely unacceptable. To quote my colleagues in the Ateneo de Zamboanga, in a statement they issued to condemn the attack on their city, “this is a crime against humanity.”

Those who are responsible for the Zamboanga City hostage-taking should be brought to justice. The so-called “Cabatangan formula”, which was used in a similar incident involving also the MNLF in 2001, should be abandoned. That formula, named after the place in Zamboanga City where the incident happened, gave the MNLF hostage-takers safe conduct passes so lives could be saved. As Mindanews, the reliable Mindanao-based online media site, has reported: “The ‘Cabatangan formula’ has been put forward as a solution to the ongoing crisis but the political cost of invoking that formula is making officials rather wary.” According to Mindanews, Zamboanga City Mayor isabelle Climaco believes that allowing the current perpetrators to once again get away without being held accountable will only repeat history. Clearly the good Mayor, who has performed exceptionally well in this crisis, has taken to heart what George Santayana once said: “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

Taking a hard stand against the hostage-takers and their leaders (at the right time, I will write about Nur Misuari, whom I have always liked and continue to respect even as I disagree with his words and actions) is not equal to supporting an all-out armed attack against them. That is not an option we can afford. First, an indiscriminate attack will only result in unacceptable civilian casualties. I cannot imagine any scenario where such an attack will not result in significant collateral damage. Second, killing many of the hostage-takers will only result in their glorification, at least in their communities, and will mean a new generation of fighters will replace them. Hence, I favor a humanitarian ceasefire without conditions to prevent further escalation. Alternatively, the current calibrated military response might work.

I have no doubt that the crisis in Zamboanga City will eventually be resolved. But we must make sure that it does not happen again. Criminally prosecuting the perpetrators and the masterminds are important but not enough. We must go to the roots of the problem, to the conditions that resulted in the current situation. The key is to change the facts on the ground - the politics, the economics, and yes the governance of this part of the country. And for that, we must return to the peace process that is the heart of both the problem and the solution.

On the side of the MNLF, there is an allegation that the Philippine government has abandoned the 1996 Final Peace Agreement between the Government of the Philippines (GPH) and the MNLF, and that this is tantamount to a declaration of war, a renewal of hostilities.

On the side of the government, Secretary Teresita Quintos-Deles of the Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process has categorically denied this. What the government wants completed is the almost six-year Tripartite Review Process (involving the government, the MNLF, and the Organization of Islamic Countries) on the implementation of the 1996 agreement, to pave the way for the it’s full implementation.  According to Secretary Deles, the Aquino administration has continuously engaged the MNLF through this Review Process as well as through peace and development programs under the PAMANA program

Some analysts have speculated that the motivation for the Zamboanga City hostage-taking is to scuttle the peace negotiations between the government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) which is now on its last stages, with marathon talks happening in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

Ironically, what is happening in Zamboanga City makes it even more imperative for the GPH-MILF peace negotiations to be successfully concluded. The outcome of the negotiations must however include ways and means to reconcile the Bangsamoro Basic Law, which is intended to implement the new agreement, with the 1996 Final Peace Agreement. More importantly, the government must take an integrated and inclusive approach in negotiating peace. As someone who was involved, on the government side, in the peace negotiations with the MNLF (as Legal Affairs Undersecretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, I cleared the natural resources and land concessions we made to the MNLF in 1996 and the MILF (in the last months of the Arroyo administration, I agreed to join the GPH panel to help in the transition to the Aquino government), I was always uncomfortable with the dichotomy between the peace processes we have pursued in Mindanao. I have come to the conclusion that the bilateral approach to negotiations must be replaced by a quad or quintet approach so that everyone is brought to the same table, including the MNLF and other groups with legitimate interests (Lumads or indigenous peoples of Mindanao  for example as well as local governments of affected areas).

Recently, the Aquino government sought to involve the MNLF in the creation of the Bangsamoro by asking for nominations for the Transition Commission but it seemed that overture was rejected. In the future, other such attempts should continue to be made. Only through such an integrated and inclusive approach can comprehensive peace be truly achieved and made permanent. Otherwise, the hostage-taking in Zamboanga City will happen again and, to paraphrase George Santayana, because we did not learn our lessons well, we will repeat the past. And next time, we will not be as lucky and hundreds more would die and the displacement even larger.

Facebook: Dean Tony La Vina Twitter: tonylavs
COMMENT DISCLAIMER: Reader comments posted on this Web site are not in any way endorsed by Comments are views by readers who exercise their right to free expression and they do not necessarily represent or reflect the position or viewpoint of While reserving this publication’s right to delete comments that are deemed offensive, indecent or inconsistent with editorial standards, may not be held liable for any false information posted by readers in this comments section
comments powered by Disqus

Want Updates?

Be the first to know on what is latest from, simply enter your email below to get started. We don’t spam dont worry!